Is the Liberal Hour Ending in the West?

  • Share

By Patrick Buchanan

Hillary Clinton called them “the deplorables.” Barack Obama called them losers who “cling” to their Bibles, bigotries and guns.

To President Jean-Claude Juncker of the European Commission, they are “these populist, nationalists, stupid nationalists… in love with their own countries.”

Well, “stupid” they may be, and, yes, they do love their countries, but last week they gave Juncker a thrashing, as they shook up the West and the world.

Elections in the world’s largest electoral blocs — the 28-nation EU, and an India of 1.3 billion people — showed that the tide of nationalism continues to rise and spread across Europe and Asia.

In India, the Hindu Nationalist BJP party of Prime Minister Narendra Modi won a smashing victory. So strong was Modi’s showing that he rushed to reassure non-Hindus, especially India’s 200 million Muslims, that they remain equal citizens. But in India the Hindu hour is at hand.


Nigel Farage's Brexit Party, formed just months ago, ran first in Britain with 31%. No other party came close. Labor won 14% and Prime Minister Theresa May's Tories ran 5th with 9%, a historic humiliation.

In the French elections, Emmanuel Macron's party lost to the National Rally of Marine Le Pen, whom he had defeated 2-1 in the last presidential election.

Matteo Salvini's populist-nationalist League, with 34%, ran first in Italy in a showing that could lead to national elections that could make him prime minister.

The nationalist Law and Justice Party in Poland and the populist Fidesz Party of Viktor Orban in Hungary were easily victorious.

In Germany, however, the conservative-socialist coalition of Angela Merkel bled support. Both the CDU and SPD lost strength in defeats that could shake the Berlin government.

What do these elections tell us?

If the Conservatives wish to remain in power in Parliament, they will have to leave the European Union and, if necessary, crash out without a divorce settlement with Brussels.

The Tories cannot defy the will of their own majority on the most critical issue in 50 years — a nationalist demand to be free of Brussels — and still survive as Britain's first party.

Whoever wins the Tory competition to succeed May will almost surely become the prime minister who leads Britain out of the EU.

Nor is that such a tragedy.

The first Brexit, after all, was in 1776, when the 13 colonies of North America severed all ties to the British crown and set out alone on the path to independence. It did not turn out all that badly.

Last week's election also saw major gains for the Green parties across Europe. Laser-focused on climate change, these parties will be entering coalitions to provide center-left and center-right regimes the necessary votes to create parliamentary majorities.

The environment is now likely to rival Third World immigration as an issue in all elections in Europe.

While nationalist and populists control a fourth of the seats in the EU Parliament, they are isolated. They may have the power to block or veto EU actions by Brussels, but they cannot impose their own agenda.

Yet even larger lessons emerge from these two elections.

Liberalism appears to be losing its appeal. A majority in the world's largest democracy, India, consciously used their democratic right to vote — to advance sectarian and nationalist ends.

Why is liberalism fading away, and nationalism ascendant?

The former is an idea that appeals to the intellect; the latter, rooted in love of family, faith, tribe and nation, is of the heart. In its potency to motivate men, liberalism is to nationalism what near beer is to Bombay gin.

To be a proud Pole, Hungarian, Italian or Scotsman has a greater grip on men's love, loyalty and allegiance than to be a citizen of Europe.

"Whoever speaks of Europe is wrong," said Bismarck. Europe is but "a geographical expression."

Identity politics, people identifying themselves by their ethnicity, nationality, race, culture and faith, appears to be the world's future.

Even leftists are bowing to the new reality.

"Identity politics is exactly who we are and it's exactly how we won," says Stacy Abrams, the African American Democrat who almost won the Georgia governor's race. "By centering communities in Georgia, we... increased voter participation, we brought new folks to the process."

The Democratic Party is now a coalition easily identifiable by race, ethnicity, ideology and gender — African American, Hispanic, Asian, LGBTQ, feminist and Green.

Our Founding Fathers believed we Americans were a new people, a separate, unique, identifiable people, a band of brothers, who had risked their lives and shed their blood. Liberals believe we are held together by abstract ideas and ideals, such as democracy, equality and diversity.

But did Washington, Jefferson, Madison, Monroe, Calhoun, Clay, Jackson, Sam Houston, Tyler and Polk really believe in equality and diversity as they drove Indians, French, British, Spanish and Mexicans out of this land to create a continentwide nation of their own?

Or was Manifest Destiny really all about us, and not them?

10 thoughts on “Is the Liberal Hour Ending in the West?”

  1. My daughter is not African-American, my other daughter is not Hispanic-American, my husband is not British-American and I am not German-American. WE ARE AMERICANS PERIOD. We are supposed to be a melting pot not a land of tribes.

    1. Breaths there a man, (woman), with soul so dead.
      Who ne’er unto themselves has said-
      “This is my own, my native land”.

    2. I agree. I disagree with the author. Nationalism is not a race game, a gender game, or anything other than One Nation, comprised of whoever chooses to be in that national melting pot.
      The only people outside the American melting pot are those who insist on remaining independent of it. It is sad to allow the elites to divide us internally so they can manipulate us like puppets.

  2. People…….
    Enough of these “liberal democrats”, trying to PAWN our country, into socialism (a nice name for communism)….These goons are TRAITORS… We have got to stand together & RID our country of these ‘idiotic ideologies’…..And yes, ICE must round up all these “so called” immigrants, who are actually ILLEGALS, & deport them immediately. Otherwise, WE ARE DOOMED…..

  3. It’s almost funny how we went from proud and united Americans after 9/11 to having identity politics shoved up our butts today. I find it encouraging that other countries embrace their nationality, and we should do the same. We live in the greatest country that this planet has ever seen, and that reason alone is enough to preserve her at whatever the cost.
    Socialism has no place in this country. No matter what the sleazy left tells you, it is an attack on all human freedoms. I’m not a selfish, uncaring person. I give whatever I can afford to those in need… but I’m not going to help the political prostitutes of today’s democrat party destroy this great country. They’ve got a day of reckoning coming, and I’ll do whatever I can to bring it about. God bless America!

  4. +I think all the time about why God gave us the Bomb , and I think it is because we are a just and caring people . We could have ruled the world with a weapon like that, but no we did just what we had to too stop the war, and then we help our friends and enemy alike rebuild and prosper no one else would have don that . God has always given us what we need to do what has to be done for all mankind ,a weapon, a soldier, grate mine ,A leader like a President. Mr Trump is rude, crude and so was Patton and think God we had him, Gen Eisenhower , and all of the unbelievable Men and Women of our Armed Forces You see that is why like it are not we are the World’s Policeman It was ordained by the all mighty who knows we will do what has to be done for all Peoples

  5. Why is it the people who are claiming to be depressed are the ones doing the separating and all at the same time choosing the white race to be the villain when it was the white race that created this great nation.
    One has to wonder what kind of nation we would be if any of those other races were in charge? Just take a good look around the world to find out.

Comments are closed.