New York Ignores the Supreme Court and the 2nd Amendment

In defiance of the Supreme Court and the Constitution, New York enacts new and heavy gun control policies this week. In June, the Supreme Court struck down a set of century-old unconstitutional gun laws in New York, but the battle isn’t over yet.

Some Background

New York has long been unfriendly to self-defense. In fact, New York’s “proper cause” requirement had been around for over one hundred years. The law, according to the Heritage Foundation, maintains a government monopoly on self-defense. It requires anyone applying for a concealed carry permit to show “proper cause” for their own self-defense. The Supreme Court Determined that this directly conflicts with the tradition of the Second Amendment.

In New York State Rifle & Pistol Association Inc. v. Bruentwo residents wanted to exercise their Second Amendment rights. They couldn’t prove that their lives were in any significant and palpable danger, so the state denied them access to a permit. The Court voted in their favor on the grounds that New York’s actions violated the Second Amendment.

In the Supreme Court ruling, Justice Clarence Thomas said that New York’s “porper-cause” requirement “violates the Fourteenth Amendment in that it prevents law-abiding citizens with ordinary self-defense needs from exercising their right to keep and bear arms.” Thomas determined that a conflict with the history of the Second Amendment is enough to strike down a law.

This ruling threatens unconstitutional gun control laws in every corner of the country. In fact, nearly every gun restriction violates the “history of the Second Amendment” and the clause “shall not be infringed.”

New York’s New Draconian Restrictions

The new “good moral character” law has several unorthodox requirements. Applicants will have to turn over three years of social media posts to prove good behavior. What are they looking for in these posts? That’s for them to decide. Anyone looking to exercise their Second Amendment rights will also have to provide multiple references to vouch for their good moral character.

As crime spikes in New York, citizens need to defend themselves. People are applying in droves for permits. In August of 2022, 9,187 people applied for permits in New York. That number almost tripled from last year. In August of 2021, only 3,187 individuals applied for permits.

Starting today, gun owners will be barred from carrying firearms nearly anywhere they might need to go. A bevy of areas are now designated “sensitive” locations including nearly all health centers, restaurants, mass transit (where a mass shooting recently took place), churches, museums, colleges, and Times Square. The list goes on.

The bulk of the new restrictions take effect today, September 1st, 2022. NY Democrat lawmakers are working to include abortion regulations in the wave of new restrictions.

New York’s governor, Gov. Kathy Hochul announced that this set of regulations is a response to the New York State Rifle & Pistol Association Inc. v. Bruen.

Someone should tell her the meaning of the phrase “shall not be infringed.”


This policy spells bad news for New Yorkers, but hopefully it won’t last long. The same reason that Bruen struck down the “proper cause” laws should apply to this all the same. There is no such thing as a “gun free zone,” where civilians are safe from criminals with no respect for the law. The truth is that criminals flock to “gun free zones” because their targets are soft and unarmed. Every American has the right to protect their life, liberty, family, home, and well being. We the people have the responsibility to ensure that the right to bear arms for every American shall not be infringed.

When you sign up to comment you'll also receive our regular newsletter. You can find more about how we use your information here.

7 thoughts on “New York Ignores the Supreme Court and the 2nd Amendment”

  1. Until there are consequences for the actions these “political buffoons” take, they will keep on going against the Constitution and the rule of law!

  2. Joe Biden got on TV and lied as usual and Blamed Republicans for their Disregard of our Constitution, but we all know Democrats Hate our Constitution, they feel if they don’t like some parts of it, they should be able to remove them and replace them with their own Ideology. Republicans believe you don’t do anything to something that has worked so well since it’s been written and made our Country the most Powerful Country on this Planet and the Envy of the entire World. “It’s that Simple”

  3. Why would anyone want to live in New York or California? High taxes, criminals running the streets, and no rights as a citizen. Sad.

  4. This gun control is a total cop out and things are turning around. How can you better control the streets of New York? By putting guns into responsible citizen`s hands. You have chosen to do the opposite by letting murderers go. Clearing out our jails and putting the criminal element out on the streets to do their crimes again. You backed defunding the police? Where did that money go? I wouldn`t be thinking ahead. My guess is the insurance companies involved before Ferguson Floid Antifa BLM were bought off. The crime rate means damaged and stolen goods. Everyone`s insurance rates have gone up. You can thank our grifter Democratic administration. I have never in my life met an angry gun. I have met criminals with guns that are causing the problems. Biden knows perfectly well. He should be jailing and putting to death murderers. Seems to me the criminal element is in charge.

Comments are closed.